Education

A friend of mine wrote that life can be divided into seven stages:



1) What is that?


2) I know that!


3) I thought I knew that.


4) Who am I kidding?


5) How did I manage to miss that?


6) Was this my journey?


7) I don't get it.




Getting your degree is the beginning of the end for stage two.




My mother graduated with a Masters in English from Otago in 1960. I got my Masters from Vic in 1998. It was while I was doing my Masters that I began to learn things. I learned that if you go far enough in academic study you tend to end up in a very small (intellectually speaking) room that you fiercely defend against people in different rooms. There might be someone in a different room, for example, that says the wallpaper colour is double Spanish white, while you maintain that it is only Spanish white. Particularly annoying people in rooms down the hallway might even argue that the room doesn't exist at all, that it is merely a cultural construction.


I also began to suspect that most of what you need to know is learned the hard way which is, generally speaking, not to be found in a lecture hall on a power point slide.


Number One: Judas


Christmas.


I read a book about Jesus and realised not for the first time that the original message was appealing: we should help the vulnerable; everyone deserves a chance.


Organised religion is a bore. There is nothing in ceremony, there is nothing in a church. The only thing that teaches us is words and experience.


In my thinking book, as a result of reading My Name Was Judas, I wrote:
"Human rights don't exist. They just don't. Human beings have different kinds of rights depending on the values of the society they live in and how that society apportions them. Sometimes human beings have no rights. For example, slaves in 19th century America, or Jews in Nazi Germany. Because human rights are specific to society there is no such thing as universal human rights."
This maybe a cliche to some, but it was an original thought for me. I always thought (without really thinking about it) that the Declaration of Independence, and the Universal Declaration of Human Rights were rather grand. And yet injustice in the world is continuous. Yet champions of human rights are assassinated. It might be, I realised after reading My Name Was Judas, that these declarations are just letters to Santa Claus.

Numbers Three & Two: Katherine


I re-read Miss Brill.
I remember walking past a group of new students at university when I was doing post-graduate study. I was wearing a ridiculous white suit jacket with shoulder pads. As I walked past them they fell silent. As I walked further on and we were able to pretend that I was out of earshot, they laughed at me and my jacket and my shoulder pads. It was not a nice feeling.
More than anything I think that this story might be about the thoughtlessness of youth.
I'm not young anymore. I'm middle-aged.

Numbers Five & Four: Christmas


Christmas was nice. I come from a very small family. I have no brothers or sisters, but I first had Christmas with my wife and daughter and as my daughter ripped open her presents with unwitting delight I had a feeling that I was a father and that being a father was in itself a gift. Then we went to my mother's place and opened presents there. The candle burning on the dining table was for my father to show he was there in our minds at least. Finally we went to my brother-in-law's new house. It was a good day. His wife looked after us generously. For me, the most devout of atheists, at the time of Christmas I think of Jesus, which is pretty odd really - for an athiest. But then it's at Christmaas that you tend to notice the difference between a bum wandering around Israel with only the clothes on his back telling people to love one another, and the rampant consumerism of the modern Christmas. This is a cliched thought that occurs to me every year. It is comforting to have recourse to cliche.

Number Six: Robert Kennedy


For along time I thought that JFK was the one I should admire. I discovered recently that it was his brother Robert. He is the one I should admire more because he was allowed four more years than his brother and his wisdom was hard won.
His speeches are not as initially moving as his brother's speeches, but they have more truth in them because he had done more suffering, and thought more about it.
Like my other great personal hero, Martin Luther King Jnr., he came to be, after decades of thought and bruising experience, anti-war, anti-capitalist, believing in the basis of good society which is love.
I strongly, strongly recommend that you visit the website called "American Rhetoric" and listen to the speeches of Robert Kennedy who was the last (?) hope of America and was gunned down in the same year as Martin Luther King Jnr. was gunned down. Listen to his brother Ted read out his eulogy, listen to his voice break. If you no longer allow yourself to weep, weep.

Number Seven: Dreams

Here's what has been bothering me over the last few days, Richard:









  1. I read a book called My Name Was Judas

  2. I told my mother about this blog
  3. I reread Miss Brill

  4. Christmas came and went

  5. I started a thinking book*

  6. I listened to the speeches of Robert Kennedy

  7. I read a book called Mister Pip

*A thinking book is a book where you write down what you've been thinking (duh)

Let's start with number seven first.

Something a character wrote in Mister Pip made me write this in my thinking book:

"A dream may be broken in two. Sometime later you realise that this is the opportunity for two dreams. You pick them up for awhile until they also fall and break. Soon you have so many broken bits that some must be discarded because there are too many to hold on to. Once your dreams have come down to the specificity of small, worn-smooth pebbles you find that you can actually make them come true. Sometimes you might pine for the original grand dream of your youth but this was silly and naive and untested against anything. These dreams that you have now are hard won. The dream of your youth was something like: "I will love like no other, I will be free, I will be like a comet in the night sky." The dream of your middle-age is: "I will give myself to my child so that she will know love, and I will learn through this how much I owe my own parents who gave me love."




Time further out

Dave says:

"To explain the relationship of the Miro painting to the music is not a simple task. I can point out the obvious link between the numbers in the upper right hand corner of the painting and the time signatures of each of the pieces on the album. There is a more tenuous link in the Miro abstract forms, suggesting human figures moving in a visual rhythym which could be interpreted as a jazz quartet."


I learned how to play the guitar at Strings 'n' Things in Paraparaumu. Strings 'n' Things was run by a German who had had a hit with his band in Germany which I think might have been called Lollipop (the hit not the band). He had a big bush of grey curly hair and a long, lean body. He taught me guitar with a couple of other boys. Basically we sat in a circle, he played the chords for simple songs and we copied him. That's how I learned how to play the guitar. This method had a major advantage and a major drawback for my musical development.
Advantage:
I learned that chords are the thing you need to know, and if you know them you can make your own songs. I have made my own songs ever since and regardless of their negligible quality I have gotten a lot of satisfaction out of this
Drawback:
I know next to nothing about music from a technical standpoint. For example it wasn't until quite recently that I really realised what different time signatures were and that a lot of my favourite bits in pop songs were when they shifted to 3/3 or 5/4 or whatever.
Which leads us back to Time Further Out by Mr Brubeck. Cool idea (each track in a different signature), and cool execution. I've listened to Unsquare Dance for years and never understood that one of the reasons it's good is the unusual time signature and off beats.
I know you can argue that music is all about feel and you don't need to worry about all that technical stuff, but sometimes I feel like I am playing in a cage, or trying to explain something very complicated in another language.
Then again, the only other time I've paid for lessons it was with a guy who wouldn't even let me touch the guitar until I had mastered written music. I would look mournfully at my guitar across the room trying to remember if it was Every Good Boy Deserves Fruit or Fruity Ardvaarks Can Eat Gooseberries. We lasted two lessons together.

Interlude IV

Up again. Down again.
Morning is a square of light
instead of darkness on the curtain.
The lawn needs mowing
The face needs shaving
This unremarkable dawn is
done by 9:15.
If he turned on the radio
he would hear the unbearable beauty
of faith transformed into song,
if he went out there might
be the chance of a smile snatched
off a child, or laughter,
or anything.
Any damn thing.

Interlude III

I loved my leather jacket

I gave it to a now vanished friend

Bought when I believed I was a Lizard
King, able to do anything
And given up when I got fat
Old and bald
When I found that I was not at all
The hoodlum I had wanted to become
But liked quiet nights in

Reading

Life's Companion


"Be my life's companion and you'll never grow old

You'll never grow old, no, you'll never grow old

Love and youth and happiness are yours to have and hold

Be my life's companion and you'll never grow old


I know a man who's lonely and he's old at thirty-three

No one wants to be old at thirty-three

Your disposition sours like a lemon on a tree

Don't let it happen to you and don't let it happen to me."
Be my life's companion (from Funny Girl)


I heard someone say that Louis Armstrong could sing anything and make you feel that everything would be ok. I'm a bit older than thirty-three now and I have a disposition like a lemon on a tree but side two of Hello Dolly really cheers me up.

Sometime this year I was beginning to find out about my father, and my mother was over for dinner. I said: "So, was my father like one of those 70's dads that never changed a nappy and wanted children to be seen and not heard?" and my mother, without missing a beat, said "oh no, he LOVED being a dad."
I had to go and hide in the bathroom and have a little cry after that. How I wished I had known him. How honoured I am to know my daughter.

A fake interest in jazz


My mother said that she had a fake interest in jazz. It never did what it was supposed to for her. I sympathise. For awhile I had a fake interest in Nick Cave. He's very moody, very trendy (in a slightly obscure way). I have listened to a lot of his albums, even a best of. I pretended it was cool, but now I have given up.




It's a funny old thing peer pressure, and you never get entirely free of it. Of course it's much worse when you're young. It's always the kids who are cool who are the biggest pains in the arse at school. If I thought a student would listen to me when I handed out unasked for advice I would say:



Don't ever try to be cool. Find out who are you are and be true to yourself.



Sounds straight forward, but it's worth remembering;



Very few people will give up trying to be cool before they're thirty, and


  1. Finding out who you are is pretty much impossible.


Aside from those two problems, it's a real pearl of advice.



The Armstrong record was my Dad's. It is a pearl. I once saw quite a famous movie (maybe High Society) in which I think it was Bing Crosby who explained to Louis Armstrong what jazz was while Louis aped goofy grins. It's all very well to say things like "to thine own self be true" but there are a lot of things against it. Society for one.

Grandad Sings Italian Opera - Volume Two

I think that The Great Caruso must have been a very influential movie. It certainly made the reputation of Lanza.

I think that Lanza, like Caruso, might have been a bit of a ham. But what the technicians forget when they criticise tenors and sopranos who are hams is that opera is also about drama. It is not sufficient simply to hit all the notes, you have to sell the song as well. Caruso could sell a song. Even though it is totally over the top to do a big sobbing intake of breath in an opera aria as Caruso does in Pagliacci I still love it because he is swept away by the drama of it all.


I have never liked art that is realistic. Art for me has always been about escape. Realistic art is false. If you want realism just open your eyes: it's a toddler reaching for food at the table; it's a mother with rollers in her hair; it's breakfast tables and net curtains. Do you think Grandad sang Italian arias in Mosgiel in the 1950s because he wanted realism?


Give me the sobbing, give me the hams.


Grandad Sings Italian Opera - Volume One


When I was a kid my mother gave away a pile of 78s. She gave them to a kid that had a wind up gramophone and collected 78s to play on it. I didn't know what 78s were at the time, or why she had them or what they meant.

They were her father's. Her father liked opera and bought 78s of people like Jussi Bjoerling, Caruso or even crooners such as Lanza. He was a decent tenor himself and liked to sing at church or embarass my Gran by serenading her while she scrubbed potatoes at the kitchen sink or shelled peas.
My grandfather was a man of dark clouds and bursts of light. I think in the days of light he must have been a man of great charm.

He died when I was five. Same year as my Dad.
My fondest memory of my Grandfather is a bike ride on the Tairei Plain. He sat me on the handlebars of his heavy, black bicycle, between his arms, and pedalled out into the long, deserted back roads behind Mosgiel. Here are the fields, and ditches overrun by weeds, the high holly hedges and hills off in the distance lying like a woman on her side.
Who knows what parts of him are parts of me, but I suppose at least I can say that he's the reason I love opera. He passed on his enthusiasm to my mother and she passed that on to me.

Even a stopped clock

Time.


I steal all my worst ideas from Richard.

Here is my class room at the end of the year. I don't wish to say anything fatuous about the year. There were times I wanted to hang myself from the rafters. There were times my students would have tied the noose and held the ladder.













Left is my wall of 2007. Right at the tippy top is a hat worn by the fine people who work at Krispy Kreme donuts in Australia. A girl in my form class brought me that back from her trip to Oz. There is an origami swan, pieces of art and a few touching portraits of myself drawn by students.













You don't get into teaching because you're vain.










When I was at Teachers' College there were two people in my study group that (or who, depending on your command of English) work at the school. I wanted to say something to one of them today:

Are you ok? I hope you're ok. You told me a story once about a ghost sort of coming and telling you everything would work out. I don't know if it will, but we survived another year. Have a good, long, stressless holiday.

Planetary Dances


While my mother was at Lorna Brown's dance classes she worked up an original dance piece set to Mars, Bringer of War from Holst's The Planets. Aside from Mars, Bringer of War and the bit that someone set to Blake and turned into Jerusalem most of this album reminds me of the theme for Star Trek. The last piece even has a female choir. If only von Holst had thought to have someone say "Stardate blah-blah-blah" over the top of it.
It was written in 1914. That means that you have to think about World War One. The liner notes say (about Mars), "It has been called a prophecy of the mechanised warfare that was to come." No. Just because there's a snare drum in there doesn't mean it has anything to do with World War One. I would say most people listening to it now would think of Darth Vader.
Holst composed 200 pieces of music. He's remembered for this. Ravel is remembered for Bolero. Rodrigo for Concierto Andaluz.
If your life was boiled down to one thing what would it be?

Interlude II

Richard has distracted me. He inadvertantly hit on the idea of remote control toilets little knowing that they already exist. While I was in Japan I often went to the toliet (sometimes up to twice a month), and I was confronted by things like this on the wall where the toilet paper should have been (see above).

It's somehow especially annoying to be humiliated in a toilet cubicle. There is a great sense that pushing the wrong button could lead to things going terribly, terribly wrong. There are two things that are intimidating. One: how can there be so many buttons when all you want to do is flush the toilet? Two: Why is there an LED display?


Here is something from Wikipedia that really captures the snappy brilliance of the Japanese mind:


"Other features may include a heated seat; an automatic lid equipped with a proximity sensor, which opens and closes based on the location of the user. Some even play music to relax the user's sphincter (some Inax toilets, for example, play the first few tunes of Op. 62 Nr. 6 Frühlingslied by Felix Mendelssohn). Other features are automatic flushing, automatic air deodorizing, and a germ-resistant surface. A soft close feature slows the toilet lid down while closing so the lid does not slam onto the seat, or in some models, the toilet lid will close automatically a certain time after flushing. The most recent introduction is the ozone deodorant system that can quickly eliminate the smells. Also, the latest models store the times when the toilet is used and have a power saving mode that warms the toilet seat only during times when the toilet is likely to be used based on historic usage patterns. Some toilets also glow in the dark or may even have air conditioning below the rim for hot summer days. Another recent innovation is intelligent sensors that detect someone standing in front of the toilet and initiate an automatic raising of the lid (if the person is facing away from the toilet) or the lid and seat together (if someone is facing the toilet).

Recently, researchers have added medical sensors into these toilets, which can measure the blood sugar based on the urine, and also measure the pulse, blood pressure, and the body fat content of the user. Talking toilets that greet the user have also started to be made. Other measurements are currently being researched. This data may automatically be sent to a doctor through a built-in internet-capable cellular telephone. However, these devices are still very rare in Japan, and their future commercial success is difficult to predict. A voice-operated toilet that understands verbal commands is under development.

It is possible to use the water jet on a high-pressure setting for an enema, and some users take advantage of this to help them with their constipation. It is also reported that women may be sexually stimulated through the water jet."

Wikipedia: Toilets in Japan


Which makes you realise how hitting the wrong button could really affect your toilet experience. Thinking that you were simply flushing you could end up having your bowel cleansed or being inadvertantly sexually stimulated.
A further question: How did the Japanese toilet designers find out what kind of music is sphincter relaxing? The mind really boggles. What kind of person would sign up to an experiment that involved laxatives and classical music? How would Mendelssohn feel about his music being chosen as the most sphincter relaxing?
I knew a girl who went to the toilet at her Japanese friend's house and pushed the wrong button. She looked on in horror as her pee fountained back over her shoulder in a long jet and saturated the calendar on the toilet door behind her.

Interlude


The way to make money is to invent something that becomes ubiquitous. Nobody would think of buying a TV that didn't come with a remote.

When I used to stay at my grandmother's place in Mosgiel she had an old TV. It had a quite nasty green synthetic dust cover. When you pulled it off you were confronted with the large wooden box that was the TV. You turned it on and then you went off to make a cup of Milo because it had to warm up. Then you came back and sipped your Milo and watched Coronation Street while your grandmother knitted. If you really had to change to the other channel you got up, walked over to the TV and pushed a button.

On the weekend I found a drawer of abandoned remote controls. They were all for old stereos. Because I have a small, easily distracted mind I thought: "Why is a TV remote indispensible, but a stereo remote unnecessary?" The answer is something like this: with a stereo you choose what you want, and you listen to it right the way through; with a TV someone else chooses what they think you might want to see (they're always wrong), and they chuck in heaps of ads. To get around not knowing what people want to see networks create hundreds of channels. To check that there is nothing on quickly you need a remote.

Conclusion: a remote is essential for a TV because TV is shit.

Flamenco Magic


"On the evening of the Pilgramage, the Gypsies gather together in their camp. On the second side of the record you will hear Manitas and his family. His brother plays the guitar with him. His sons, his cousin and his nephew sing, and during this Provencal night they are all present for you, singing, dancing, playing for your pleasure which, today, thanks to this record, is also yours."
This album. This is the jewel in the crown of the collection for me. Manitas' playing is so rough, raw and percussive. Side Two, the live side, is fantastic. Somehow I have never been bothered by not understanding what people are saying when they sing (sorry to the guys who wrote Carmen Jones), it has always been about conveying emotion for me. The wonderful thing about listening to these guys sing is that they are like the brass section in a jazz band, doing their long bluesy runs, and filling in each others gaps, while underneath are the clapping off-beat hands, and pulsing heavy guitar rhthyms. Strong stuff when I was a kid.
About as far away from this as you can get is the "New Flamenco" of Ottmar Liebert. I have two of this man's CDs and have been to one of his concerts. All because my friends knew that I loved flamenco and were being kind. I think enough time has passed for me to say (1) thank you for your generousity, and (2) German flamenco! Oh dear. It sounds like it is being performed by robots. The back of Liebert's CD says (please read it with a fake German accent): "we are dedicated to a process of continuous refinement both artistically and commercially. As in music, so in life." Dreadful. Reminds me of another slogan: "Work Makes One Free." Yeah, right.
Ottmar Liebert appeals to one thing in man, and Manitas de Plata appeals to another. I have always been on the side of Manitas.

Lorna Brown teaches creative dance


Early in my mother's marriage she started going to classes in creative dance held in a room in Otago University in the Physical Education Department. They were taken by someone called Lorna Brown. There were about a dozen people in the class, and they danced to a variety of records including Spanish stuff requiring castanets, shawls and a shuffling mastery of footwork.
When I was a kid one of my toys was a pair of black plastic castanets held together with a piece of red string. Of course I didn't know what they were or how to operate them. They seemed a very cryptic children's toy. Funny how your parents' lives before you were born don't exist when you are a child or a teenager. When you are a teenager you are utterly impervious to the idea that your parents were once young, and felt the things you felt and hated the things you hated.
Then you get older of course. Age does bring perspective. Strangely this reminds me of a piece I read in a book at the beginning of the year. The person writing is a very old Jesuit priest, and he says:
"I am sometimes very conscious that I am following a leader who died when He was less than half as old as I am now. I see and feel things He never saw or felt. I know things He seems never to have known. Evedrybody wants a Christ for himself and those who think like him. Very well, am I at fault for wanting a Christ who will show me how to be an old man? All Christ's teaching is put forward with the dogmatism, the certainty, and the strength of youth: I need something that takes account of the accretion of experience, the sense of paradox and ambiguity that comes with years."
Although my father lived to a reasonable age he died when I was five. It struck me this year that I really knew nothing about him. Am I taller than him? What did his voice sound like? All those photos of my mother and me... he was there, in the room, holding the camera and pushing the button. I really think he must have loved the woman he married. He supported her in the barbarian culture of 1960s Otago to take fashion courses, to do a Masters, to dance.
This interest in dance, and the weekly dance classes, leads to what is for me the iconic album in the collection.

Dorothy Dandridge? She was some kind of coloured singer.

My mother bought this after going to see the movie starring Dorothy Dandridge and Harry Belafonte. My mother said that seeing this movie in the late 1950s blew her mind. She thought Dandridge was a fantastic Carmen, and the music and dancing were wonderful.

On the back of the LP Hammerstein says when he was a kid he went to the opera, liked the music but thought it was silly they were all singing in Italian. Listening to his version I think it's silly they're all singing in English. Frankly the toreador's song is not quite the same when it's about boxing and he says things like "punch him smack on the nose."

Nevertheless, my mother passed on the Carmen gene to me. I was brought up on Carlos Sauras' version of Carmen. The Carmen Jones version starred Dandridge and Belafonte but they were both dubbed. So the record has neither of them on it. Dandridge's career didn't pan out very well.

The Dancing Shearer



My mother first met my father at a wedding, and afterwards they went to a Joe Brown dance at Dunedin's town hall.

My father was at the wedding because he worked on the family of the groom's farm shearing sheep. He sheared sheep to pay to go to university. My father didn't have a really great upbringing, he was brought up by a prickly Aunt, but he was decent at school, good at sport and a great ballroom dancer.

How did someone with his background get to be a good ballroom dancer? My mother wasn't sure. Anyway, when she first met him he had three records: Mantovani (Immortal Classics / Tangos) and Belafonte. So these are my dad's records from the 1950s.

When I was a teenager in Paraparaumu it was all the rage to fill up old 1.5 litre Coke bottles with water and leave them all over your front lawn. It was supposed to stop dogs doing their business on your property. It got to the point where every single lawn in Paraparaumu had these plastic Coke bottle droppings on them (usually with dog dropping in between). There were various theories why this was supposed to work. The only one I remember was that the dogs were supposed to be frightened of their reflection in the water bottle. Of course it didn't work. In fact it is utterly ridiculous. Nevertheless, thousands of adults littered their lawns with old Coke bottles in the belief that it did work.

This is very hard to understand twenty years later. Which is a bit like me trying to understand the world's fascination with Mantovani in the 1950s. It is completely lost on me. What kind of world are we dealing with?

Tango?



Back to this guy again? Mantovani and his sodding orchestra. I've listened to this a few times now and tried to like it but I really can't find much to like.

When I sat down with my mother and her records she put them into groups, and the first group she made was the Belafonte record and the two Mantovani records.

Why? Any ideas?

P.S. - There's no more Mantovani. I promise.

Calypso


This album is wonderful. Released in 1956 it was the first LP to sell a million copies in the USA. It is very hard to be depressed and listen to this album. What a great cover.


For years I had this memory of a book I had been made to read at school. It was about a boy living on an island and he was obsessed with Harry Belafonte. For a long time I had no idea who Harry Belafonte was (even though he was sitting in my mother's record collection). One day I dragged this out, dusted it off and gave it a spin. Brilliant.


Belafonte was heavily involved in the civil rights movement in the 1960s. He was mentioned in a History textbook that I use to teach about the civil rights movement. I played the class Day-O. They were horrified (but secretly enjoyed it). Belafonte is still around annoying American presidents by telling them they shoudn't be killing people in foreign countries, they should be building houses for the poor. Hillary Clinton refuses to talk to him. I mean, what an outrageous thing to say: houses for the poor! Sounds like communism to me. Follow this link and look at his comments.


Many years after I read that book I was talking about, still at school but now a teacher, I was leaving my classroom after the day was over. It was a windy, high-cloud day, rubbish blowing through the halls and across the field, and out of the sky dropped a book. Some student had thrown it on the classroom roof and it now flapped its way to my feet. It was called The Cay and I realised as I picked it up that this was the book I had read twenty years ago at school.

At left: Harry Elefonte, with Belafonte

Immortal Classics


So hugely does this album feature in the collection that we may need to come back to it.
Mantovani Plays the Immortal Classics, Decca (1953). I see that Mantovani also released four other albums in 1953 including I suspect the less than immortal An Album of Christmas Music.
It's hard not to make fun of Mantovani. Even the fan website is defensive:
Quality Light Orchestra Music is sometimes confused, with "background music, or "easy listening" music, it surely is not.... Another Mantovani friend of mine, when someone mentions "Elevator Music," states, "Show me that elevator!"
Have you ever heard of a category of music called "Quality Light Orchestra Music"? You will be relieved to hear that there is a new biography of Mantovani out. One reviewer cryptically comments:
As years pass, we realize that art glows at different angles when and where it is examined and experienced. And generally the world is looked at differently afterwards.
Sure.
The thing is I rather like this record. I like it for two reasons.
Firstly, I love things that were once enormously popular and have now vanished off the radar. Mantovani fits the bill. The first person to sell a million stereo records, phenomenonly popular in Britain and America, one of the recording stars of his era. Now he would be unknown to everyone under fifty.
Secondly, the little sticker my mother put on the album cover says: "Please keep this record. It is very old, but it takes me back to when I first met M. and contains two of my most loved pieces of music: Handel's Largo and Schubert's Ave Maria."
When I was a kid my mother had a tape of something like the London Pops Orchestra playing classical tunes. It had, predicatbly, a version of Pachelbel's Canon on it. It was an "interpretation" of that piece and it ended with a french horn. The thing is I never knew until I was a lot older that it was an interpretation and I got rather attached to that french horn. Even now when I hear versions of Canon I am always listening for the surging horn at the end, and always disappointed when it doesn't happen. My point is, with some songs it doesn't matter if the first version you hear of something is a supposedly "inferior" - it will become the version that matters most for you.

Not the one in the hat

Guess which one is Mum.

This might be my favourite photo of my mother. She looks very "contemporary" although this photo must be from the early 1960s. Of course it was the early 1960s in the far south of New Zealand so we should subtract at least a decade in terms of fashion. Looking at family photos from this period you get the strong feeling that living in Otago in the 1960s was not quite the same as living in America in the 1960s.
It was at this time that my mother was building her record collection with my father. What a strange, eclectic collection it is. It both proves and disproves the theory that if you wait long enough everything comes back into fashion.

Mum's Records

Awhile ago my mother gave me all her records. Some of them have little stickers on them. They say prosaic things like: "Return to W." and far more personal things such as "play at funeral". The first note is in case I get hit by a bus tomorrow and somebody going through my stuff knows not to biff the record. The second note, well, it's sort of obvious.

One day I took the record collection and a notebook to my mother's house and asked her to talk about each record as it came up. I thought it might be a bit of her history that I didn't know about. It's an odd record collection, and I wanted to know what fitted it all together. We spent an afternoon together. I suppose it's a kind of musical biography of my mother.

Eleanor

As I got older I got cockier. I started to think that I knew stuff. Turns out I didn't know anything. I've taken my lessons this year from Eleanor. She turned one today.

Lessons:

  1. Even though I'm a misanthropist with a pessimistic view of human nature I learned that one of the first things we find out how to do after we're born is smile and laugh.
  2. We take things for granted about being human. You have to learn how to do everything. You have to learn that you exist, that your hands are your hands, that you can move them, that you can do things with them. Every single one of us walking around, so sure of ourselves, so confident in our gestures and expressions, began not even knowing that we existed.
  3. And I learned what unconditional love is.

Happy birthday, Eleanor.

Kids that steal books are cool kids

ONE


He complained to his friends that his only readers were the kids who stole his books from stores.



(p.286)



I went to the library yesterday to get books by Kerouac. There weren’t any on the shelf. I looked them up on the catalogue and the catalogue said that they were all kept at the desk. I went to the desk and asked for a book by Kerouac. The young girl behind the counter said “which one,” and then went and got the book I asked for. She went to a set of shelves groaning with Kerouac, picked out my book and handed it to me. “Why?” I asked. She sort of looked at me and then said: “Everybody steals them”. I was so surprised I forgot to look at the shelf of books-people-want-to-steal and see what other knick-able authors I should be reading.

Kerouac was right. His only readers were kids who stole his books (and former kids reliving their youth). Critics, well, they rarely liked Kerouac it would seem.

John Ciardi took him apart in Saturday Review, Robert Brustein went after him in ‘The Cult of Unthink’ in Horizon, John Updike parodied his style in a short story for the New Yorker, Truman Capote attacked him on David Susskind’s TV program by saying that what Kerouac did wasn’t writing at all, ‘it’s typing’.



(p.287)



Which seems mean, but then Kerouac’s books weren’t written for Bobby Bumstein, and John Uptight, and Fakeman, and you wonder why Kerouac let himself be hurt by them in pointless interviews and silly lectures.

Weschler shouted ‘We have to fight for peace’ (eternal quote) and Jack looked at him in exasperation, said ‘What? Don’t you realise that doesn’t make sense?’ or something like that; then sat down silent but with Weschler’s hat on his head. Weschler got mad and angrily demanded his hat back; as if Jack were a barbarian just like he dreamed, taking his hat!

Hunter College debate, 6 November, 1958 (p.275)



Kerouac was shy and anxious and got drunk to protect himself before interviews. Critics in newspapers hammered him. Former poetic acquaintances mocked his poems in newspapers.

People who are disparaging about your creative efforts are especially hurtful. They can be hurtful by returning your work unmarked without comment, and they can be hurtful by returning it heavily annotated and by never ceasing in their diatribe of feedback. It is a hard, hard thing to maintain friendship and be a critic, and you should always have the right to refuse to read your friend’s books, squibs or half-baked ideas.

If the critics were dangerous then so were the fans.

They tended to drive their cars more recklessly when he was with them, as if he was ‘Dean Moriarty’, and not the Kerouac who hated to drive and whom I had once seen crouching on the floor of a car, in a panic, during a drunken six-hour dash from New York to Provincetown. They plied him with drinks, they created parties around him, they doubled the disorder in the hopes of catching his eye, and so never glimpsed the Kerouac who once confessed to me, ‘You know what I’m thinking when I’m in the midst of all that – the uproar, the boozing, the wildness? I’m always thinking, What am I doing here? Is this the way I’m supposed to feel?

(John Clellon Holmes, p.276)



Remember this is all 1956-1958. We are in a time that is just getting the hang of new words like “rock ’n’ roll”. The world described by Kerouac is pretty wild by today’s standards. Imagine it in the days when Elvis shocked the world by twitching his hips.

The young people who responded to the book, who read it not as ‘literature’ but as an adventure, recognized that Kerouac was on their side, the side of youth and freedom, riding with Cassady over American highways chasing after the great American adventure – freedom and open spaces, the chance to be yourself, to be free. Kerouac hadn’t offered any real alternative to the conformity of twentieth-century industrial America. He ducked the problems of the 1950s such as the Bomb, the pressures of the Organisation Man, McCarthy’s Un-American Activities Committee. He offered instead a vision of freedom, a return to a solipsistic world of childhood, to an irresponsibility so complete that no other world could ever intrude for long. If he’d started across America too late to join up with the wagon trains, the cowboys roaming the range, the I.W.W. organisers or the Dust Bowl refugees, he’d nevertheless carried on with their uncompromising search for freedom, for the chance to see if a better life couldn’t be found by moving on, for the great American dream.

(pp.264-5)



The Great American Dream sounds about as vague as the: it-means-what ever-you-want-it-to-mean, oxymoron called Pakeha Identity.


TWO


I had always believed that the myth of On the Road went something like this: Jack meets up with a crazy guy called Neal and they whiz around America; Jack types it all up in a week high on drugs; the book gets published; Jack becomes an overnight sensation.

Jack first met Neal and started doing road trips in 1946/47 and On the Road was published in 1956. The famous three week “that’s not writing it’s typing” version (1951) was not his first or last draft of a book that it took him years to write. It was the break-through draft of course, the draft where Kerouac freed himself and discovered something he would come to call spontaneous prose; the style of prose that he became (in)famous for. By the time On the Road was actually published Jack had written something like eleven unpublished books which he lugged around in a rucksack when he went on the road.
The months right before success hit Kerouac with a cobblestone right and a left hook sort of summed up those ten years. His last job before being “discovered” was sitting up in a hut on Desolation Peak for two months watching for fires in complete isolation. At that time he wrote this about himself:

Take another look at me to get the story better (now I’m getting drunk): - I’m a widow’s son, at the time she is living with relatives, penniless… I’m 34, regular looking, but in my jeans and eerie outfits people are scared to look at me because I really look like an escaped mental patient with enough physical strength and innate dog-sense to manage outside of an institution to feed myself and go from place to place in a world growing gradually narrower in its views about eccentricity every day – Walking thru towns in the middle of America I got stared at weirdly – I was bound to live my own way … I was also a notorious wino who exploded anywhere anytime he got drunk – My friends in San Francisco said I was a Zen Lunatic, at least a Drunken Lunatic, yet sat with me in moonlight fields drinking and singing … I was an Ambitious Paranoid – Nothing could stop me writing big books of prose and poetry for nothing, that is, with no hope of ever having them published.

(pp.250-1)


After his stint in isolation Kerouac headed for Mexico stopping by Neal’s house on the way, but

he became restless with what he thought was a serene family life with the children, the swimming pool, the pizza pies and the never-ending TV quiz shows and advertisements.

(p.249)


This is a surprising picture of Dean Moriarty/Neal Cassady considering what we usually think:

Kerouac presented such a compelling portrait of Neal Cassady [in On the Road] that his image fashioned the life style of a generation of young readers who came of age in the 1960s and 1970s. In the pages of On the Road, Cassady emerged as an archetypal American hero.



(p.262)


Actually this version of Neal Cassady did fashion the life style of a generation – the generation in the majority – the generation who got jobs, settled down, and watched TV.

Once in Mexico Kerouac called on his friend Allen Ginsberg to come and join him, and Allen and his entourage did, also stopping at Neal’s.

After spending the night at Neal’s, where Gregory had a nightmare about eggs and couldn’t face breakfast, the four of them, Allen, Gregory, Peter and Peter’s brother Lafcadio, went on to Los Angeles.


(p.252)

(The only reason I included that quote was because of the egg nightmare.)

There was a slow-building feeling of expectation now for this haphazard bunch of writers. Ginsberg’s Howl readings were getting more of a following; Kerouac’s On the Road was moving towards actually being published. Finally it seemed that this group of no-good bums who had been talking themselves up for a decade were going to make it. They went from Mexico, to New York, to Tangiers, to New York. Kerouac was characteristically moody and depressed. He drank; he isolated himself. Back in America Kerouac went with his mother to Berkley. It was there that his publisher sent the first box of books called On the Road.

Memere had gone to the store and Jack was completely alone in their shabby apartment. Holding the books in his hands for the first time, he looked up as ‘a golden light’ appeared in the porch door. It was Neal, dropping by with his old girl Luanne and two other friends. In Desolation Angels, Jack described the scene, a moment in his life that haunted him forever:
We all stare at one another in the golden light. Not a sound. I’m also caught redhanded (as we all grin) with a copy of Road in my hands even before I’ve looked at it for the first time! I automatically hand one to [Neal] who is after all the hero of the poor crazy sad book…

Kerouac felt guilty, almost like a thief, with the book in his hands, but he felt even worse after Cassady looked at it. ‘When [Neal] said goodbye to all of us that day he for the first time in our lives failed to look me a goodbye in the eye but looked away shifty-like – I couldn’t understand it and still don’t – I knew something was bound to be wrong and it turned out very wrong…’



(p.260)

When I first read On the Road I thought it was the beginning of an amazing story.

It was the end.


Almost all of Kerouac’s brilliance, restlessness and poetry were spent by the time On the Road was published, and much of the time until his death was spent publishing back catalogue. Before America turned its attention on him Kerouac was free; afterwards he was the best-selling author of On the Road and he was in a cage explaining what BEAT meant. Pointless. You may as well steal your opponent’s hat, you may as well laugh out loud at the man who has nightmares about eggs.


All page references are to:
Kerouac: A biography by Ann Charters
Andre Deutsch, London, 1974

Childhood


"Lowell, Massachusetts is an early nineteenth-century textile town built on the banks of the Merrimack River, thirty miles north of Boston. Settled largely by Polish, Irish, Portuguese, Greek and French immigrants, it was a resolutely working-class town, where men worked five-and-a-half days a week and walked home for lunch, while the women cleaned, cooked and reared their children in Greek Orthodoxy or Roman Catholicism. Every ethnic group formed a close-knit community. There were five French parishes alone in Lowell, a French language newspaper and school where all the lessons were in French." (p.29)


Kerouac – Angelheaded Hipster
Steve Turner, London: 1996, Bloomsbury


This multi-lingual town doesn't really fit in with my mental map of America. It sounds very tribal: "The French Canadians were called Canucks, and spoke a crude patois, joual, which led to their being scorned as outsiders. They lived in ghettos called ‘Little Canadas,’ intermarried, and regarded everyone outside the tight little community with a suspicion bordering on paranoia. Unfortunately, their narrow-mindedness and racism found their way into Kerouac’s novels, but their unity and bravery are also woven into his life and work." (pp.7-8)


Subterranean Kerouac – The Hidden Life of Jack Kerouac
Ellis Amburn, New York: 1998, St. Martin’s Press

You get a sense of this tribalism when Kerouac's daughter describes meeting her father for the second time in 1967. She went to Lowell and looked in the phone book:
"I was astonished to see a whole list of Kerouacs. I'd never in my life seen my name in a directory.... I began by calling the ones spelt like mine, and before I knew it we were at the home of Doris Kerouac, amid a crowd of stocky French-Candian relatives, all excitedly speaking patois and embracing me. 'The daughter! Jean never told us he had a daughter!" Shaking their heads and gesticulating, they bore us over to Jack's house on an ocean wave of strength, morality and good will.... So these were my people, hearty people with souls of gold. I wanted to stay with them and belong."
Baby Driver
Jan Kerouac, New York, 1981
No wonder Kerouac spent his life bouncing back and forth between wanting to escape the smothering attention of his hometown and mother and hitting out on the road, and the other half of the time trying to get back home where he felt secure.
Many of Kerouac's biographers say that everything Jack wrote was biography and all of Jack's narrators were personas that he had been busy inventing since he was a kid imagining himself as an American football star. He reinvented himself, and his home town over and over again in his books. Childhood is strong stuff. Parents take care.

Fathers

"Leo Kerouac was sicker than ever and it was apparent to Jack and memere that he wouldn’t live long. He was in pain, irritable and cantankerous. Every two weeks the doctor climbed the stairs to the apartment to drain his stomach of fluids, and Jack would hear his father in the kitchen wincing and groaning, and then weeping as the doctor left. There was no more talk about Jack throwing his life away. Leo made him promise he’d always take care of memere whatever else he did, and Jack promised.

Leo Kerouac died in the spring of 1946. Jack and his mother followed his hearse to the family cemetery in Nashua, New Hampshire, where he was buried. When they returned to the still apartment in Ozone Park, memere did her spring house cleaning and went back to work at the shoe factory. As before with the death of his older brother Gerald, Jack was overcome with grief and a sense of personal loss. It seemed to him, as he forced himself to pick up the outlines for his projected novel, that death was the greatest mystery, the greatest theme for literature. Grimly he settled down to write the novel he had planned earlier in the year. He had taken Thomas Wolfe as a model, but his book was really written for his father, to prove to the memory of Leo Kerouac that Jack could write a book that would sell, that he could be a creative writer.

Jack had failed to fulfil his father’s dreams of seeing him a football champion, a success at college and a hero in the Navy. At each one of Jack’s failures, Leo Kerouac had supported him, confronting the Columbia football coach and the Navy psychiatrists as though his Ti Jack could do no wrong. But privately, at home, the arguments had raged between father and son. Jack felt that Leo had never believed in his promise as a creative writer, so he would prove himself there where everything else had gone awry." (pp.53-4)


Kerouac – A Biography by Ann Charters
Ann Charters, London: 1973, Andre Deutsch Limited.

Jack's original beginning to On the Road was about his father:


"I first met Neal not long after my father died... I had just gotten over a serious illness that I won't bother to talk about except that it had something to do with my father's death and my awful feeling that everything was dead."
On the Road

He changed it so it was about his first wife; a woman he had married to get bail after being an accessory to a murder.

"Kerouac would remember [his father] as a dynamic, jovial hustler.... 'I see now his true soul, which is like mine - life means nothing to him,' Jack once observed. In the Kerouacs' divided household, Jack sided with his mother against his father, accepting her judgement that Leo was 'a drunkard and didn't... give a shit.' " (p.12)


Subterranean Kerouac
Ellis Amburn, New York, 1998


People who vanish out of your life can becoming dominating characters. They put pressure on your personality and the way you act. Kerouac's father and Neal's father both seem to be looming presences in the background of On the Road. Even though it is Kerouac's mother who is often talked about, Kerouac's father can not be discounted as a major force in his life.

I come across this photo and wonder: What's he looking at? What's he thinking? After the shutter clicked what did he do, where did he go?


Breathless Prose


I've been reading about Jack Kerouac. I've been reading about what Jack read when he was young and impressionable.

"The Houde brothers introduced Jack to the first English language writing to inspire him, in comic books such as The Green Hornet, Operator 5, Phantom Detective and The Shadow. He particularly identified with the mysterious character of The Shadow, ‘Shrouded, unseen observer, black-cloaked and black-hatted.’….


Although it appeared with a comic book cover, each bi-weekly edition of The Shadow was a novel-length story of 60,000 words, written under the pen-name Maxwell Grant. Most of the episodes that Jack read would have been written by the prolific Walter Gibson, who was responsible for 285 Shadow comics in the 1930s.


In fact, Gibson’s descriptions of how his Shadow stories were composed sound almost exactly like Jack’s later descriptions of what he would call ‘spontaneous prose’. “By living, thinking, even dreaming the story in one continued process, ideas came faster and faster,” Gibson once said of his 30,000 words-a-week output. “Sometimes the typewriter keys would fly so fast that I wondered if the keys could keep up with them. And at the finish of the story I often had to take a few days off, as my fingertips were too sore to begin work on the next book.


This ferocious work schedule resulted in a breathless prose which was studded with colourful descriptions of fog-enshrouded cities and lingering evil, in which Jack half-recognised his own dreams and fears."

Kerouac – Angelheaded Hipster
Steve Turner, London: 1996, Bloomsbury



Breathless prose. I think that's a pretty good description of those parts of On the Road that describe parties, and bad driving and jazz. The bits that I think of as the best in Kerouac.